July 15, 2025

Episode 329: Building with Purpose with Eduaide

Episode 329: Building with Purpose with Eduaide
Spotify podcast player badge
Goodpods podcast player badge
Apple Podcasts podcast player badge
Amazon Music podcast player badge
Pandora podcast player badge
RSS Feed podcast player badge
Spotify podcast player iconGoodpods podcast player iconApple Podcasts podcast player iconAmazon Music podcast player iconPandora podcast player iconRSS Feed podcast player icon

Ep.329 Building with Purpose with Eduaide

In this episode, I welcome back two familiar voices: Thomas Thompson and Thomas Hummel, the powerhouse team behind Eduaide.AI. This isn’t just another conversation about AI. It’s a grounded, honest discussion on what it means to build tech for teachers, by teachers.

We talk growth, grit, and grounded design. From their classroom beginnings to becoming one of the most trusted teacher-first platforms, we unpack how they’re putting pedagogy over hype, and purpose over buzzwords.

🎧 If you are skeptical, curious, or cautiously optimistic about AI in education, this is a great episode for you.

 ⏱️ Timestamps: 

00:00 Introduction and Context Setting
06:46 EduAid's Growth and Development
14:09 Feedback and Teacher Engagement
20:56 Pedagogy and Technology Integration
22:16 Community Feedback and Its Impact on EduAid
23:38 International Reach and Localized Curriculum
26:29 Access and Equity in Education
28:23 The Ripple Effect of EduAid
32:34 Navigating AI in Education
35:18 The Hype and Reality of AI Tools
39:37 Public Education vs. Private Success
46:24 Revisiting Taxonomy of LLMs in Education
53:20 Challenges of AI Integration in Schools
56:31 Navigating the AI Landscape in Education
01:03:09 Grounding in Reality: The Educator's Perspective
01:11:02 Innovations in EduAid: Enhancing Teaching Tools
01:17:04 Final Thoughts and Reflections on Education and AI

 🫶 A huge thanks to our incredible sponsors for supporting this work:
Eduaide.AI, Book Creator, Yellowdig

🛠️ My EdTech Life is about real conversations that matter. No buzzwords, just honest dialogue with the people building the future of learning.

🙏 Like, comment, and subscribe to keep these conversations going—and as always… Stay Techie, my friends.

Peel Back Education exists to uncover, share, and amplify powerful, authentic stories from inside classrooms and beyond, helping educators, learners, and the wider community connect meaningfully with the people and ideas shaping education today.

Authentic engagement, inclusion, and learning across the curriculum for ALL your students. Teachers love Book Creator.

Support the show

Thank you for watching or listening to our show! 

Until Next Time, Stay Techie!

-Fonz

🎙️ Love our content? Sponsor MyEdTechLife Podcast and connect with our passionate edtech audience! Reach out to me at myedtechlife@gmail.com. ✨

 

00:30 - Welcome and Introduction

05:19 - Meet the EduAid Co-Founders

15:34 - EduAid's Growth and Efficacy Studies

28:49 - Navigating AI Hype in Education

41:54 - The Reality Gap Between Vendors and Schools

53:07 - New EduAid Features and Community Focus

01:13:23 - Final Thoughts and Billboard Wisdom

WEBVTT

00:00:30.096 --> 00:00:33.457
Hello everybody and welcome to another episode of my EdTech Life.

00:00:33.457 --> 00:00:38.585
Thank you so much for joining us on this wonderful day and wherever it is that you're joining us from around the world.

00:00:38.585 --> 00:00:41.091
Thank you, as always, for your support.

00:00:41.091 --> 00:00:42.908
As you know, we appreciate all the likes, the shares, the follows.

00:00:42.908 --> 00:00:43.631
Thank you so much for your support.

00:00:43.631 --> 00:00:44.899
As you know, we appreciate all the likes, the shares, the follows.

00:00:44.899 --> 00:00:46.622
Thank you so much for your comments.

00:00:46.622 --> 00:01:07.250
We take this to heart because we completely want to improve and bring you some amazing conversations, as we always do into our space so we can continue to grow, and today is no different, and I am excited to welcome our very first four-time guest and our third well, I can say fourth, actually third-time guest.

00:01:07.250 --> 00:01:12.393
We have Thomas Thompson and Thomas Hummel from Edu8 joining us today.

00:01:12.393 --> 00:01:15.349
Thomas Thompson, how are you doing today?

00:01:16.460 --> 00:01:22.850
Well, thank you so much for having us today, fonz, for the fourth time, you know I feel like the privileged list of guests.

00:01:22.850 --> 00:01:24.308
You know the Tonight Show.

00:01:24.308 --> 00:01:27.304
They would have the 10 comedians that would get to do repeat appearances.

00:01:27.304 --> 00:01:28.245
So it's an honor.

00:01:28.727 --> 00:01:32.805
Yes, no, fourth time guest for Thomas Thompson and Thomas Hummel.

00:01:32.805 --> 00:01:36.612
You are a three time guest now, so that's a wonderful honor.

00:01:36.612 --> 00:01:37.742
How are you doing today?

00:01:38.123 --> 00:01:42.784
Fonz, I'm doing great, and it's always a pleasure to get to speak with you, so thank you so much for having us.

00:01:43.385 --> 00:02:06.884
No, thank you, and I'm really excited to have you all here and, as all my listeners know, and I always, when I close out the show and thank all my sponsors you are a sponsor of my EdTech life and I want to thank you for believing in our mission and what we're doing to just continue to bring some great conversations into this space and just see where we stand, where we're going, how we're growing, and just kind of take it from there.

00:02:06.884 --> 00:02:14.650
You know, right now, I think that having dialogue is great and just having those conversations continue as the technology continues to grow.

00:02:14.650 --> 00:02:16.282
It's something that's very important.

00:02:16.282 --> 00:02:19.331
So I'm really excited to get into today's conversation.

00:02:19.431 --> 00:02:28.366
However, we may have some first-time listeners or some first people that are learning about EduAid for the very first time.

00:02:28.366 --> 00:02:36.251
As you know, we were just at ISTE and you know a lot of conferences and in the summertime usually a lot of teachers get to dive into a lot of tools.

00:02:36.251 --> 00:02:41.198
So before we get into the meat of the conversation, I'll go ahead and start off with Thomas Thompson.

00:02:41.198 --> 00:02:49.592
Can you give us a little brief introduction and what your context is, not only in the EduAID space, but in the educator space as well?

00:02:56.039 --> 00:02:57.426
Yeah, of course my name is Thomas Thompson, co-founder and CEO at EduAID.

00:02:57.426 --> 00:02:59.418
Prior to and in current with starting EduAID, I was a middle school social studies teacher.

00:02:59.418 --> 00:03:02.590
That's how I met Thomas Hummel, one of the other co-founders of EduAid.

00:03:02.590 --> 00:03:05.621
Taught in rural Maryland on the eastern shore.

00:03:05.621 --> 00:03:07.486
Did that for three years.

00:03:07.486 --> 00:03:12.084
Then I was starting graduate school, said okay, I can't be driving an hour to work every day.

00:03:12.084 --> 00:03:15.763
I started teaching in Glen Burnie, maryland, just north of where I live in Annapolis.

00:03:15.763 --> 00:03:17.606
Did that for another two years.

00:03:17.606 --> 00:03:19.693
We launched EduAid at that time.

00:03:19.693 --> 00:03:27.450
That sort of got out of hand so I had to step away from teaching and focus on EduAid full time and happy to do it.

00:03:27.450 --> 00:03:31.062
We bootstrapped this thing with three people, one of those being Thomas Hubble.

00:03:31.925 --> 00:03:33.230
Excellent, Thomas.

00:03:33.230 --> 00:03:33.993
How about yourself?

00:03:33.993 --> 00:03:38.932
Tell us a little bit of your context within the education space and in the EduAid space as well.

00:03:39.294 --> 00:03:39.615
Yeah.

00:03:39.615 --> 00:03:42.364
So I'm just like really blessed to still be teaching.

00:03:42.364 --> 00:03:48.564
I think that anybody who goes into teaching they do it because they love it, not to get rich or anything like that.

00:03:48.564 --> 00:04:00.467
And so you know, I feel very fortunate to have a great team like teammate, like Thomas here who kind of can take over a little bit more on the edge weight side as far as all things going with the business.

00:04:00.467 --> 00:04:14.169
But you know, just on the teaching side, I think it's great that we have the ability to implement our tool into the daily practice that no other company really can do, because you know, we're just teachers and we're just trying to help teachers.

00:04:14.169 --> 00:04:22.562
So it's awesome to be part of this journey and also remain like committed to my community and to my students.

00:04:22.642 --> 00:04:48.829
So I feel very, I feel very blessed, fonz, excellent no, and that's wonderful and I think that's something that is great about both of you and the work that you're doing from the very beginning, really still kind of your foot in the classroom, foot in EduAid and still being able to see how it is that you can continue to improve your platform, you know, on the daily, on the monthly, on the yearly, and just to continue to help educators.

00:04:48.829 --> 00:04:55.805
And I know that there are many educators out there that are extremely thankful for the work that you're doing and the work that you've done from the very beginning.

00:04:55.805 --> 00:05:12.548
As I know, and personally, in having you all on the show various times and various phases of EduAid, it has been something wonderful to see your growth and really how you continue to enhance the, not only the platform.

00:05:12.548 --> 00:05:45.209
As we know, many people can come up and, you know, have critiques about platforms but the fact that you listen and listen to those even the critiques but also listen to teachers to help improve the platform and really stick to that pedagogy-based learning that is really reliable and can help teachers not necessarily feel that they're doing something completely different or learning something new, but really enhancing what they are already doing, is something that has been great and that's something that I love to catch up on.

00:05:45.600 --> 00:05:54.968
You know, from the last time that you guys were here, back in episode 282, you know, I know that a lot has changed from 282 to this being 328.

00:05:54.968 --> 00:06:03.593
And although the number seems very close, there are definitely months, months and many months going through there and a lot of growth in EduAid.

00:06:03.593 --> 00:06:10.069
So, thomas Thompson, I'll go ahead and start with you as we kind of dive in into the growth of EduAid.

00:06:10.069 --> 00:06:31.774
From the very last time that you were here, as you guys were planning on going and doing some efficacy studies and really diving in deep and hearing from educators to see how you can improve, can you please share with us a little bit of your findings and how that has helped you continue to improve the platform but also improve the learning in the classroom as well?

00:06:32.639 --> 00:06:35.041
Yeah, certainly, I mean from.

00:06:35.041 --> 00:06:36.624
It has been quite a few months.

00:06:36.624 --> 00:06:43.449
We've launched a few like really intensive partnerships with some other organizations that have allowed us to take a really close look at our platform.

00:06:43.449 --> 00:07:04.387
So we worked with a cohort of teachers at Teach for America in a kind of a controlled study over a set number of weeks and we had these kind of meetup calls and they played around on some platforms, implemented them in their class to set a few objectives that they shared with the cohort, and it was just great getting a lot of the feedback from those folks.

00:07:04.387 --> 00:07:30.694
Really, a bright group of teachers, super committed, had a lot of great notes on not only things that we could add some different ways of thinking about how we approach certain subjects but then also like the positive feedback too, hearing from teachers who were new teachers, veteran teachers as well, coming across new and diverse methods of instruction they didn't previously consider or having supplemental resources they wouldn't have previously had access to.

00:07:30.694 --> 00:07:32.607
I mean that's quite rewarding.

00:07:33.620 --> 00:07:43.074
The other piece of this, however, is you want to go beyond making teachers feel as though they're doing something effective or feeling efficient.

00:07:43.074 --> 00:07:45.649
Right, this is just the first step, kind of the tip of the iceberg.

00:07:45.649 --> 00:07:56.627
Really we are looking at the largest bottlenecks being validation, verification of the AI outputs themselves that you're putting into the instructional context, and prompting.

00:07:56.627 --> 00:07:59.509
I mean prompting and verification are really the two large bottlenecks.

00:07:59.509 --> 00:08:05.252
We got a long way to do kind of more of that alignment work on our side.

00:08:05.252 --> 00:08:14.535
So we have a partnership currently where we are looking with CZI, the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative, using their evaluator tools.

00:08:14.535 --> 00:08:39.405
This allows us to really get in on a very fine level and look at text complexity and sentence structure and ensure that when you're selecting different grade levels on EduA, that's coming through in the outputs from the AI and that we're able to better constrain the AI for those grade level texts and then just continue to expand out our knowledge graph of learning sciences research that we use to make rubrics and kind of grade the responses ourselves while we're testing and developing them.

00:08:40.000 --> 00:08:42.288
That's been a pretty rewarding experience.

00:08:42.288 --> 00:08:47.326
I'm pretty happy with where that knowledge graph is and how these prompts are looking and how things are coming out now.

00:08:47.326 --> 00:08:49.125
So I mean a lot of work there.

00:08:49.125 --> 00:08:53.748
But you know those just streamed wall of text got old pretty fast for most people.

00:08:53.748 --> 00:08:56.927
So it's like we went the way of like really highly structured outputs.

00:08:56.927 --> 00:09:04.004
So graphic organizers, venn diagrams, freya model stuff, marking the text, exercises, really structured games, so like.

00:09:04.004 --> 00:09:06.830
These things are themed, templated, formatted.

00:09:06.830 --> 00:09:08.232
You have total control over all of it.

00:09:08.232 --> 00:09:18.373
You could change the colors, change which pieces are there, add a collaboration activity with one click, take it away, add in a summarization or retrieval questions or whatever.

00:09:18.373 --> 00:09:22.850
It's all very modular, really easy to use and really in a classroom ready package.

00:09:23.672 --> 00:09:24.052
Excellent.

00:09:24.111 --> 00:09:51.297
I love it and, like you mentioned, classroom ready package is something that's great and one of the things that I love and I'm going to bring it up too, because, of course, having you guys on the show is I know that you guys really emphasize that pedagogy first, not just the tech, as being the core to EduAid, because normally it's like, hey, there are are several platforms out there and it's really all about the tech and how I can do this and make this easier for you, which is, you know, in many ways, something that is great.

00:09:51.336 --> 00:10:06.032
You know, as part of my research that I'm doing through my dissertation, I know that that's a major component as far as the ease of use and doing some certain selective tasks a lot quicker, but I love the fact that you focus more on that pedagogy and that practice.

00:10:06.032 --> 00:10:37.043
So, thomas Hummel, I want to ask you, you know, just in continuing kind of with this idea of what I asked Thomas T about you still being in the classroom and being able to use this and work with this in the classroom and get feedback, and you know what has that been like and what are some of the things that you have been excited about since the last time that you were on the show yeah, it's funny fawns like uh, you know, every teacher has their own identity and my identity sort of is like the first teacher in the building kind of guy.

00:10:37.544 --> 00:10:42.482
So I'm up early and I do a lot of my planning for the school day in the morning.

00:10:42.482 --> 00:10:54.868
Just because year 10 coming up, it's just like I don't need to go home and spend tens of hours a week doing this kind of stuff, like I have everything sort of how I want it, but it needs to be adjusted.

00:10:54.868 --> 00:11:24.916
And that's where we're finding, like where we've really made some serious enhancements with edu8 is like when I go in in the morning and I start to adjust my lessons to make them higher quality and things are not working the way that I need them to work as the teacher in the moment, I blow these guys up on the phone and I'm like I'm calling that you know, and the one guy, our buddy Ty, he lives out in Denver like I'm waking him up, you know, three days a week sometimes because we only want to put out the best possible product that we can for teachers.

00:11:24.916 --> 00:11:29.948
And if I'm a teacher and I'm running into snags on our product, what are we doing?

00:11:29.948 --> 00:11:38.280
We're not actually making it easier for people, and so we've really tried to refine out any difficult problems in our product, with working with it.

00:11:38.863 --> 00:11:42.048
But, like Thompson was saying, you know the quality of our outputs.

00:11:42.048 --> 00:12:11.460
We spend a lot of time, you know, running the same thing on multiple sites and checking it and just making sure that what we're providing is of the highest quality that we can get for teachers and not just framed in a way that's like you know, a lesson plan, but framed in a way that it's reaching the certain taxonomy level, it's reaching the certain amount of questions that need to be done and just finding little ways to improve our product to help teachers.

00:12:11.460 --> 00:12:27.403
I think if I create something and it only gave me two questions or three questions and I needed five, most of the time just little things like that make a huge difference for teachers because we need to save them time when time is of the essence and time is valuable for those teachers.

00:12:27.403 --> 00:12:28.566
So excellent.

00:12:28.726 --> 00:12:31.423
No, and that, like you said, you've kind of hit the nail on the head.

00:12:31.423 --> 00:12:34.655
I know that for sure on one of your LinkedIn posts.

00:12:34.655 --> 00:12:45.730
And if you haven't followed Thomas H, or even Thomas Thompson, too, on LinkedIn, please do, because they do provide and share just a lot of wonderful content and they're completely transparent about their app.

00:12:45.730 --> 00:12:59.383
And even, just like Thomas H I know you've put up a lot of posts too you know you still being in the classroom and, like you said, being there early, leaving there late and talking a little bit about you know the way teachers feel at the end of the year and everything that you go through.

00:12:59.383 --> 00:13:12.989
So that's one of the things that I feel is a little unique, actually a lot unique in the fact that you are still in the classroom while still being a lot easier for teachers to use, not just the tool but giving them great pedagogy.

00:13:12.989 --> 00:13:15.230
So, thomas T, I want to come back.

00:13:15.230 --> 00:13:16.831
Can I touch on that real quick?

00:13:16.831 --> 00:13:17.571
Yeah, of course.

00:13:35.916 --> 00:13:37.517
It's not just me at this point.

00:13:37.517 --> 00:13:53.809
Right Like we, we are so lucky with our product to be where we're at that we spend one day a week literally going over feedback from our teachers and we get so much feedback about the quality of what we're doing and what we're putting out there that we spent that Thursday meeting.

00:13:53.809 --> 00:14:04.403
We'll sit there and we'll just go through all this feedback and then we'll go implement these things and then, if it's you know, we try to make sure that we're doing the best from the people that we're trying to serve.

00:14:04.403 --> 00:14:16.254
So it's not just me that's using this, but it's over 800,000 teachers at this point that have used this thing and it's like we really respect their professionalism and we really value their feedback.

00:14:16.254 --> 00:14:17.826
So it's not just a me thing.

00:14:17.826 --> 00:14:19.745
It's like this whole thing with community.

00:14:19.745 --> 00:14:20.128
It's like-.

00:14:20.659 --> 00:14:22.407
Community makes doing the app much easier.

00:14:22.407 --> 00:14:32.014
There's the constant source of inspiration, ideas, and instead of turning away from them, especially at the critical moments, it's important to lean in and understand that they're coming from you.

00:14:32.014 --> 00:14:37.052
Even if the messaging is frustrated, it's coming from a place of professional frustration.

00:14:37.052 --> 00:14:43.205
They have a job they want to do well, and these tools were promised or given to them as a way to do that.

00:14:43.205 --> 00:14:50.073
And if they don't, then we're doing a disservice to a very important enterprise, which is public education.

00:14:50.094 --> 00:15:07.951
Yeah, Well, thomas Hage, kind of going back into this, this is a nice segue as far as getting that feedback, and, just like you mentioned, thomas Hage, I mean, you've got thousands upon thousands of users, not only here in the US, though, but I want to talk a little bit about this internationally, because that was a nice segue, because I was just thinking too.

00:15:07.951 --> 00:15:13.376
You know, there are several people that I have seen and followed that are using EduAID.

00:15:13.376 --> 00:15:28.695
You know, in Africa, they're using it in other countries, so I want to ask you you know and we'll start off with you, thomas T you know, as far as, like you mentioned, the feedback and the evidence that you receive from international users, you know, how have you taken that?

00:15:28.695 --> 00:15:30.788
How has that influenced your product?

00:15:30.788 --> 00:15:39.235
And also, especially, you know, with localized curricula, how has that been for you to adjust to that?

00:16:10.529 --> 00:16:14.120
Yeah, I mean the adjustment period wasn't too difficult, right?

00:16:14.120 --> 00:16:18.955
We keep it pretty open in terms of what our tool was able to do.

00:16:18.955 --> 00:16:36.373
So when we focus on the particular pedagogical aspects of the tool, so whether it's retrieval practice, distributive practice, self-explanation, elaborative interrogation, whatever the specific method might be right, those methods are generalizable regardless of locality, regardless of country of origin.

00:16:36.373 --> 00:16:43.504
The main difference there comes in the particular content of what the instructor is teaching, not the method that they would use to teach it.

00:16:43.504 --> 00:16:46.475
Necessarily, the method should vary, though, depending on the context.

00:16:46.475 --> 00:16:47.376
I'll be clear about that.

00:16:47.376 --> 00:16:56.735
We leave it really open for the user to input that contextual information where they can upload a document with their curricular materials to use as the basis for a generation.

00:16:56.735 --> 00:17:02.740
If there's a particular standards database that they have to work from, we're able to ingest those as well.

00:17:02.740 --> 00:17:05.912
And of course, cedre is offered in multiple different languages.

00:17:05.912 --> 00:17:10.701
Now we have specific standards tools for US-based standards.

00:17:10.701 --> 00:17:13.754
I mean kind of our bias, given that we're developing in the US.

00:17:13.754 --> 00:17:18.843
So common core math, common core English, next generation science, things that we're looking at.

00:17:18.843 --> 00:17:24.352
Bringing in the IB curriculum is definitely an area of interest and importance as we're working with newer international schools.

00:17:25.674 --> 00:17:33.918
But generally I mean the biggest gap is, of course, the ability to access the tool right.

00:17:33.918 --> 00:17:38.417
That in itself is the biggest barrier, not so much barriers within the tool.

00:17:38.417 --> 00:17:39.690
There are linguistic barriers.

00:17:39.690 --> 00:17:47.738
There are barriers in like sampling, for example, like the kind of things the AI will provide, as examples tend to be kind of US-based.

00:17:47.738 --> 00:17:59.958
That's not just an Eduate thing, that's a general AI phenomenon currently, like you know, the same thing would have happened if you were to use a school AI or magic school or any of these other players in foreign countries.

00:17:59.958 --> 00:18:07.956
If you're building on top of the foundation models developed in the US, using mostly English corpa, you'll run into the same issue.

00:18:07.956 --> 00:18:08.813
I mean.

00:18:08.813 --> 00:18:30.629
So the independent testing I think Hummel correct me if I'm wrong, was it Ken Sheldon who does this where he'll test a particular historical topic that, depending on the context, can be either framed in a US basis or framed in a few other different contextual bases as well, and usually the AI will default to the US examples in his prompting.

00:18:30.730 --> 00:18:33.680
So I mean it's definitely a gap, something that you have to continue to work on.

00:18:33.680 --> 00:18:37.356
It is prompting, so I mean it's definitely a gap, something that you have to continue to work on.

00:18:37.356 --> 00:18:51.177
But for us, again focusing on the pedagogical moves, the methods being at that level, that certainly, I think, helps us kind of translate EduAid into other countries and around the world.

00:18:51.177 --> 00:19:17.054
But to the access piece, I mean we have the EduAid scholarship program where we just kind of give access to EduAid away for free to folks who otherwise might be able to get their hands on it or it's prohibitively expensive, whatever it might be, because we're coming from a perspective where we view education as a public good, as a foundational human right, and the methods and materials to support instruction, I mean they should just be as open as and accessible as the instruction itself.

00:19:17.153 --> 00:19:27.616
Like, if you're locking those behind very strict paywalls, yeah, you got to keep the lights on, like that's one thing, but if you make it totally inaccessible, I mean I think it's a crisis that we see in research and science right now.

00:19:27.616 --> 00:19:29.830
A lot of the great papers are locked behind paywalls.

00:19:29.830 --> 00:19:31.874
Independent researchers are basically locked out.

00:19:31.874 --> 00:19:37.961
I mean, who's got $35 to drop on one research article or, you know, thousands of dollars for a collection?

00:19:37.961 --> 00:19:43.382
So I mean those gaps are always top of mind as we're building and trying to expand access to the tool.

00:19:43.903 --> 00:19:45.611
Yeah, no, absolutely Just kind of.

00:19:45.611 --> 00:19:49.968
Before I go back to Thomas H, you know talking about, you know paywalls.

00:19:49.968 --> 00:19:55.275
I mean even just myself having to do research and finding articles, and then all of a sudden it's like, hey, here's the link.

00:19:55.275 --> 00:19:58.338
And then all of a sudden it's like well, you got to pay this and you got to pay that.

00:19:58.338 --> 00:20:00.340
I was like excellent academia.

00:20:00.340 --> 00:20:13.961
You know I'm trying to get information to continue to grow and continue to do the research, and there it is, and but I get it.

00:20:14.161 --> 00:20:14.501
You know.

00:20:14.501 --> 00:20:18.253
You know, within the international schools and even here locally.

00:20:18.253 --> 00:20:24.419
I know that for a fact and I've heard many of my friends too as well say that they're very thankful for the work that you're doing in that.

00:20:24.419 --> 00:20:30.809
And so, thomas H, kind of going back on that too as well, in your experience, you know in the classroom too as well.

00:20:30.809 --> 00:20:36.458
You know being able to get that feedback from just international educators.

00:20:36.458 --> 00:20:38.580
You know what does that feel like.

00:20:38.580 --> 00:20:45.857
You know building something that is now not only in the hands of US teachers but also internationally.

00:20:45.857 --> 00:20:54.323
You know what are some of your big takeaways and how has that helped you continue to grow within EduAid and Edu altogether.

00:20:54.824 --> 00:21:03.480
Yeah, I mean when we first started this Fonz, I think that anybody will be surprised at where this has gone.

00:21:03.480 --> 00:21:16.404
I mean the workspace flow that we've made right you see that almost everywhere now, which is crazy and all kinds of different products, and so we just feel really blessed to be able to bring this to teachers and all over the world.

00:21:16.404 --> 00:21:27.865
And, specifically, something that I'm super proud of is that there's a lot of teachers in the Kenya area of Africa that don't get especially like the rural part.

00:21:27.865 --> 00:21:34.291
They don't have a whole lot of access, and we've been able to tap in through LinkedIn or different places, different venues of social media and stuff.

00:21:34.291 --> 00:21:37.000
But we've been able to tap in through LinkedIn or different places, different venues of social media and stuff, but we've really connected with them.

00:21:37.000 --> 00:21:44.683
And we've guaranteed life subscriptions to the Million Teacher Movement in Africa, which spans across multiple countries.

00:21:44.683 --> 00:22:09.432
We've guaranteed life access to EduAid for that, and so you know, while we've only given away a few thousand accounts already, which is still a lot right, like, if you added up the numbers financially, it would be a ton of money for us but we are just so lucky to be in a spot where we can do the good that we set out to do and that it doesn't like prevent us from also maintaining the business that we have.

00:22:09.432 --> 00:22:36.983
And so, uh, things like the million teacher movement, things like our scholarship program, uh, it just it brings me so much joy to help teachers save time and to create higher quality lessons, because the ripple effect of that doing that good piece is like you don't know where that's gonna go, but you know that the ripple is there and that it's going to expand, and so it just really gets me.

00:22:37.269 --> 00:23:27.676
I have imposter syndrome sometimes because I walk into my school in my cheap, crappy little Volkswagen car and yet my product's being used in Africa or being used in Vietnam you could go down the list In 120 different countries that day it's going to be used and it just it really makes me feel weird about myself in some regards, but it also gives me a sense of pride and, yeah, even more than that, like I now feel responsible, like I don't know if I had to and, thomas, I don't know if you feel that way, but we at least I do I feel responsible for doing the right thing in this space and that when you have teachers who are people that are just trying to do good and you kind of have them using that product.

00:23:27.917 --> 00:23:30.330
There's a huge responsibility there To not.

00:23:30.330 --> 00:23:39.435
You know, we don't want to make them feel any way, but you know better about their job and that's it Like.

00:23:39.435 --> 00:23:51.280
We want them to feel energized, we want them to feel good about teaching and, at the end of the day, if people love teaching even more because of our product, we've done so much good in this world that you can't even wrap your head around pretty much.

00:23:52.590 --> 00:23:58.413
And that's excellent and you know that's something that is great, thomas, and I think that's something that is definitely you should be proud of.

00:23:58.413 --> 00:24:12.016
You know in that and I know imposter syndrome a lot of us deal with it, you know in that sense but just the fact, like I said, it's just a testament of the hard work and consistency that both of you have been able to do and bring since the very beginning.

00:24:12.016 --> 00:25:24.726
So I love that and you know, that's something that I really do appreciate from you all and the work that you're doing, because there's LinkedIn posts upon LinkedIn posts also the international teachers just stating how thankful they are to be able to have access to a tool, a platform like yours to be able to do what they do best and enhance that learning and be able to help their students continue to learn in that so I kind of yeah, go ahead.

00:25:24.767 --> 00:25:40.577
I think that this comes out of the fact that thomas and I started teaching in a really low income, like hurting area, and we didn't you know, we didn't set out to like change the world right off the get-go, but we did set out to make a difference in the areas that need it the most.

00:25:40.577 --> 00:25:58.536
And that's why I think whenever things like that, like the million teacher movement, pops up in africa and we can support that, I think that that just resonates so much more with how we started this thing well, I kind of want to change the conversation over a little bit as and we'll come back to a couple of questions that I do want to ask especially you.

00:25:58.877 --> 00:26:06.159
You know a recent substack that Thomas Thompson pushed or, you know, pushed through I think it was today and so on that really caught my attention.

00:26:06.159 --> 00:26:12.860
But I want to ask you you know I just came back from Misty and I mean, really, it's AI is all the rage.

00:26:12.860 --> 00:26:15.198
You know there's so many platforms.

00:26:15.198 --> 00:26:22.979
I think my biggest takeaway I won't say what the platform platform was, but their spiel was.

00:26:22.979 --> 00:26:25.791
They kind of caught me in an aisle as I was just kind of walking and they're like hey, have you heard of our app?

00:26:25.791 --> 00:26:27.615
And I was like no, I haven't tell me a little bit more.

00:26:27.615 --> 00:26:33.163
And they're like well, you see, these apps over here they help the teachers before the lesson.

00:26:33.163 --> 00:26:37.855
These apps over here help the teachers after the lesson, but we help them during.

00:26:37.855 --> 00:26:40.201
And I'm like like, okay, tell me more.

00:26:40.201 --> 00:27:02.955
And he goes oh well, it's an app that you download and your teacher wears either the phone around their neck or is somehow mic'd to their phone and it really just kind of keeps those notes and again, I guess either offer suggestions or some kind of you know write up afterwards and so on, some kind of you know write up afterwards and so on.

00:27:02.955 --> 00:27:04.139
And to me I was like, well, what about student voice?

00:27:04.139 --> 00:27:05.243
And what, if there's you know that PII?

00:27:05.243 --> 00:27:07.170
Oh well, the teacher wears the mic.

00:27:07.170 --> 00:27:11.872
It shouldn't the students, you know, you shouldn't be able to hear the teacher voice, and so on.

00:27:11.872 --> 00:27:15.639
And so there's a lot, a lot of tools that are out there.

00:27:16.300 --> 00:27:23.436
Now, of course, with that, there's a lot of people that are kind of in the middle and try and be in the middle, like myself.

00:27:23.436 --> 00:27:29.057
There's also, of course, you've got, you know, people that are just really on the AI hype train.

00:27:29.057 --> 00:27:31.682
There's others that are still kind of wait and see.

00:27:31.682 --> 00:27:49.150
So there's people at different levels and, as we even saw, just the advocacy that has come up and the skepticism of AI and education, you know, as we see Microsoft and do this push, you know, with other platforms and, of course, aft, you know, giving this alarm of.

00:27:49.150 --> 00:27:51.173
You know teachers are here.

00:27:51.173 --> 00:27:56.339
We don't have to worry about getting AI being replaced by AI.

00:27:57.240 --> 00:28:11.546
How is that, you know, for you all, both as founders, as educators, as people that are trying to do good, how do you navigate that tension on the day to day?

00:28:11.546 --> 00:28:25.800
Do you just really lean into the hype or do you respond, you know, to that pushback, you know, in not necessarily pushing that pushing people back, but you know and maybe justback, you know, and not necessarily pushing that pushing people back, but you know and maybe just saying, okay, well, this is kind of that pushback that we get.

00:28:25.800 --> 00:28:27.035
How might we adjust?

00:28:27.035 --> 00:28:30.793
So I want to start off with you, thomas H first, and then we'll start.

00:28:30.793 --> 00:28:31.858
We'll go to Thomas T.

00:28:33.671 --> 00:28:35.398
Thomas, maybe he should go first.

00:28:35.398 --> 00:28:36.801
I'm the unhinged one.

00:28:37.110 --> 00:28:38.574
Okay, all right, we'll let him go first.

00:28:38.594 --> 00:28:53.350
First, I'm the unhinged one, okay alright, if I start, who knows where this is gonna end yeah, I'll begin by saying I think hype is the reason why the statement believe half of what you see and none of what you hear probably so salient.

00:28:53.350 --> 00:29:02.912
Ultimately, I worry in that I know teachers have been burned by educational technology on quite a few occasions.

00:29:02.912 --> 00:29:07.604
Historically right, the promise of personalization has been around since like 2008,.

00:29:07.604 --> 00:29:18.234
And it was going to be MOOCs that are going to lead to true personalized learning and supreme access and lack of a need for structured institutions and things like this.

00:29:18.234 --> 00:29:44.019
But ultimately, I worry that too much focus on AI will lose sight of how we should be designing these tools, which is an understanding, or at least a theory of mind, of how people actually learn, of how people actually teach, of how people actually develop, and that if your tool does not in some meaningful way interact with one of these three domains, it's like what's the purpose of the tool at that level?

00:29:44.019 --> 00:29:51.234
It's like the tech being kind of inserted in as a substitution of something you already do.

00:29:51.234 --> 00:29:59.930
It might not be, it's not good enough at that point, like the technology should not just be merely substituting something you could already do, but hey, it's a new platform.

00:29:59.930 --> 00:30:04.267
It should like in some meaningful way interface with what you do on a day-to-day basis.

00:30:04.366 --> 00:30:07.231
So we try to avoid the hype.

00:30:07.231 --> 00:30:18.612
We kind of have a strict rule internally where we try to avoid like using like the buzzwords in conversation, because it's just kind of easy to like hide what you really think behind some of those terms.

00:30:18.612 --> 00:30:23.371
So we just try to speak as simply and precisely as possible.

00:30:23.371 --> 00:30:29.988
I mean just off, pretty thorough and delicate and how you kind of phrase things, but in general it's just like get to the base of the problem.

00:30:29.988 --> 00:30:40.473
And the base of the problem is okay, you want to assist teachers at the level of planning, so maybe they're slightly more efficient, feel less pressure, burnout, these kinds of things, but more.

00:30:40.473 --> 00:30:45.190
Finally, more crucially, we want to bridge that gap between research and practice and education.

00:30:45.190 --> 00:30:55.426
With a high translation cost of trying to be a highly effective teacher, trying to translate kind of just rolls of thumb, like space your practice, bring in new concepts into practice.

00:30:55.426 --> 00:30:56.028
But like when?

00:30:56.028 --> 00:30:56.930
When to space?

00:30:56.930 --> 00:30:58.882
When do I bring in new concepts?

00:30:59.142 --> 00:31:07.752
Generative AI has an incredible amount of promise there, but it's not the everything tool Thinking you can put students in front of AI tutors and it's going to solve education.

00:31:07.752 --> 00:31:12.252
I'm not really sure that's where we should be going.

00:31:12.252 --> 00:31:22.042
One reason is, I think a lot of technologists discount the embodied human factors that are important for teaching and learning.

00:31:22.042 --> 00:31:25.066
I mean, why does a lot of in-person instruction work?

00:31:25.447 --> 00:31:28.510
Humans have a tendency towards conformity, I think, in general.

00:31:29.833 --> 00:31:40.245
So when you're working with a group of other students, your peers and a mentor figure in the classroom, there's this pressure to conform right and our kind of natural hardwiring kind of goes for that right.

00:31:40.265 --> 00:31:54.629
But if you unmoor us from that group environment where we're interacting with our peers and interacting with the authority figure, and I'm just sitting in my room on a computer talking to an AI chatbot, where's that pressure, where's the desire, where's the motivation, where's the engagement?

00:31:54.629 --> 00:32:01.676
I mean, those are all pieces that I think are generally lacking and why we see lackluster returns from AI tutoring systems presently.

00:32:02.298 --> 00:32:10.228
It's really difficult to do that, especially when you can say IDK three times and the AI tutor just gives you the answer and it's like well, okay, so what's the theory of learning there?

00:32:10.228 --> 00:32:13.124
Are we suggesting that it's just exposure to correct answers?

00:32:13.124 --> 00:32:14.167
No, not quite.

00:32:14.167 --> 00:32:17.301
So it's like what's the purpose of the AI intervention?

00:32:17.301 --> 00:32:24.014
What is the purpose of the tool, what are the unique affordances, what are its boundaries and how do you adopt that into your unique context?

00:32:24.014 --> 00:32:29.589
And if you don't have answers to those questions, as a developer, you probably question your motives.

00:32:29.589 --> 00:32:37.322
That might have been strongly worded, but I figured if I come out strong maybe Hummel will help bring it down, or he's just going to keep us climbing here.

00:32:37.322 --> 00:32:37.783
I don't know.

00:32:38.143 --> 00:32:38.663
Yeah, I don't know.

00:32:38.663 --> 00:32:40.526
Maybe that might have calmed him a bit.

00:32:40.526 --> 00:32:45.711
But, as always, I'm definitely very interested in, thomas H, what you have to say about this.

00:32:45.711 --> 00:32:47.192
I mean, you've seen the space.

00:32:47.192 --> 00:32:50.517
I know you're very active on LinkedIn and all social media.

00:33:00.448 --> 00:33:08.494
And so you see it, all I out of alpha school, where their kids all scored in the top two percent of the state on the state testing.

00:33:08.494 --> 00:33:13.306
And if you don't have an education background, why would you not send your kids there?

00:33:13.306 --> 00:33:15.509
You know what I mean.

00:33:15.509 --> 00:33:23.212
Why would you not give them the opportunity to be in the top two percent like everybody else that has gone to that school?

00:33:23.212 --> 00:33:41.245
And so, while I think that you know that is not real for everybody and I spend most of my time as a teacher trying to engage and motivate my students rather than, you know, necessarily diving into the curriculum all the time and actually learning new things, right Like, there's a huge part of my job.

00:33:41.245 --> 00:33:50.047
That is the engagement piece, that is the motivating piece that a chatbot can never do and that a student who is not motivated will never get anything out of.

00:33:50.047 --> 00:34:01.148
But there is a select bit of students who are highly motivated, whose parents are sending them to schools like the Alpha School and those other things and they're performing super well.

00:34:01.148 --> 00:34:04.623
And I get really worried, fawns is that.

00:34:04.623 --> 00:34:14.922
I think last time we talked about this there wasn't any data out on the, on the alpha school testing and stuff like that, and I was like, oh, who knows if you put your kids in front of a chat bot and all this stuff.

00:34:14.922 --> 00:34:33.909
But when they have a really good performance, like those kids did this last year, I do think it puts public education on a pretty shaky ground sometimes Just because we're not getting great results all across the nation from our schools.

00:34:33.909 --> 00:34:41.590
In fact, we're getting subpar results across the nation from our schools, and so I don't really know what the answer is.

00:34:41.590 --> 00:34:44.128
I don't have an answer, but I do.

00:34:44.509 --> 00:34:47.043
I do know that you know I have a son.

00:34:47.043 --> 00:34:53.724
We are looking at new areas to move because the school district at which I teach is not that great.

00:34:53.724 --> 00:35:02.103
It's a five out of ten on zillow, uh, and the only thing I'm looking at when I go to a new school is a 10 out of 10 school.

00:35:02.103 --> 00:35:14.596
When I'm looking at new houses, it's for a 10 out of 10 school, and I'm not the only one that's like that in the world and people move to new areas based on the quality of the school and trying to do what's best for their kid.

00:35:14.596 --> 00:35:17.079
And so I don't know.

00:35:17.338 --> 00:35:30.496
As a teacher, I'll tell you right now I would never put a chatbot in front of my student, because I know it's a probabilistic model and that if it makes a mistake which it will because of probability that I would be on the hook for that.

00:35:30.496 --> 00:35:43.505
But as a parent, fonz, if I have an opportunity to send my kids to a school where everybody's scoring in the top 2% and it doesn't cost me anything extra for X, y and Z reasons, what are you going to do?

00:35:43.505 --> 00:35:48.840
And, of course, you're going to choose what's what you think is going to give your kid the best results.

00:35:48.840 --> 00:35:55.220
And so I get really worried that we've pushed some subpar tools into public education.

00:35:55.220 --> 00:36:01.171
And here we are with some private schools that are doing a great job at getting their students to perform.

00:36:02.012 --> 00:36:08.351
I'm not sure that the conversation, uh, doesn't skew in that direction here in the next few years.

00:36:08.351 --> 00:36:09.253
I'm not, you know.

00:36:09.253 --> 00:36:10.403
I mean, I believe in teachers.

00:36:10.403 --> 00:36:21.644
I think teachers are the best people on earth, I think they make the biggest impact you could go down the list but that's not how our society feels about teachers and that's certainly not how our society feels about education.

00:36:21.644 --> 00:36:34.644
And I get worried whenever chatbot based schools are having super great results and what that means for education as a whole, what that means for public schools, what that means for people in low-income areas.

00:36:34.644 --> 00:36:43.820
Everything that I've been working towards and I think last time I had a really like cynical view on this perspective like, uh, you know, chatbots not good.

00:36:43.820 --> 00:36:49.682
Putting Abraham Lincoln in front of students is a lie if it's a chatbot and all these things, which I still believe in.

00:36:49.682 --> 00:36:56.704
But some of the results that are coming out from people are insane and, um, it makes you think.

00:36:56.704 --> 00:37:03.481
It certainly makes you stand back and think about what this means for education yeah, no, that makes perfect sense.

00:37:03.541 --> 00:37:18.132
I know, when I was researching alpha school because there's one here locally in my area that's about an hour and a half away, which is very in the same city now that uh, the star base is for, uh, you know, uh, the rocket launches and everything.

00:37:18.132 --> 00:37:23.387
So I'm pretty sure that that'll be the school that'll continue to grow, especially with what they charge with tuition.

00:37:23.387 --> 00:37:30.990
But before and this was before they got all the hype I know that they had their curriculum up on the website and then all of a sudden it came down.

00:37:30.990 --> 00:37:37.133
But the last time I checked I know that they were using IXL for math, which is really just.

00:37:37.133 --> 00:37:43.572
You know, you go in there, students can go select a specific skill and they just kind of sit there and practice the skill.

00:37:43.572 --> 00:37:45.527
I don't know what else they added.

00:37:45.527 --> 00:37:52.193
I know for the high school they used to use some of the Play-Doh software, which is really like credit recovery software that they would use.

00:37:52.193 --> 00:38:01.271
But now you know, it's very interesting to see what it is that they would use and I may have to take them up on an offer on a tour that they offered me.

00:38:01.271 --> 00:38:04.945
Take them up on an offer on a tour that they offered me.

00:38:04.945 --> 00:38:11.652
So just to kind of see what it's all about, and especially the local one here, and see like, as you said, you know there are some, you know it's coming out, there's data that's coming out.

00:38:11.652 --> 00:38:24.295
As far as that is concerned, my thing is is always just even within a school district where I work at, it's always the Southside kids have more access to things outside of school.

00:38:24.295 --> 00:38:30.764
So you know the outside tutors and things of that sort, and it always was that they would do better because they would have that access.

00:38:30.764 --> 00:38:38.711
Or you know a parent at home where the Northside kids it was, they didn't have that support at home, and so I know that that plays into a role of those things.

00:38:38.711 --> 00:38:44.470
But one of the things, and one of the things too, though, is that I feel like every student can learn.

00:38:44.470 --> 00:38:45.171
You know it's not.

00:38:45.171 --> 00:38:50.249
I just don't like the fact that they say, well, you know it's, it's the Northside kids, it's expected.

00:38:50.249 --> 00:38:52.740
No, you know we got to raise those standards too.

00:38:52.740 --> 00:38:54.584
But anyway, that's a whole other conversation.

00:38:55.063 --> 00:39:04.360
But kind of talking back and talking about, you know, chatbots and talking about LLMs, I know, thomas T, you posted something on LinkedIn.

00:39:04.360 --> 00:39:05.884
It was actually today.

00:39:05.884 --> 00:39:09.713
You know you were revisiting you know taxonomy here.

00:39:09.713 --> 00:39:11.403
Let me get the actual title of that.

00:39:11.403 --> 00:39:15.253
It says Revisiting a Taxonomy of LLMs for Education Application.

00:39:15.253 --> 00:39:22.487
So and I know you wrote a really nice post there, very descriptive You've got you know talking about domains and subdomains and things of that sort.

00:39:22.487 --> 00:39:38.780
So I want to ask you you know, in writing this and revisiting this, you know like and I love the subtitle it says a taxonomy is a picture of the thing, a particular form.

00:39:38.780 --> 00:39:41.983
Tell me a little bit about your thought process as far as writing this sub stack and the information that you shared here.

00:39:42.003 --> 00:39:45.347
So I thought that was pretty insightful as writing this sub stack and the information that you shared here.

00:39:45.347 --> 00:39:46.548
So I thought that was pretty insightful.

00:39:46.548 --> 00:39:47.688
Yeah, so it's essentially just taking a look at the.

00:39:47.688 --> 00:39:52.854
It's like 20 authors on this paper Wong is the head author 2024,.

00:39:52.854 --> 00:40:02.700
The paper is called Large Language Models for Education a Survey and Outlook, and they proposed essentially a taxonomy of different instructional implications of LLMs.

00:40:02.700 --> 00:40:05.128
You've probably seen it circulated all over the place.

00:40:05.128 --> 00:40:08.706
Even if you don't know listeners, if you don't know what I'm talking about, you've probably seen the chart.

00:40:08.780 --> 00:40:27.530
It's like academic research, study, assisting teach, assisting adaptive learning tries to essentially catalog all the different domains of large language models, and I think the reason why the title is what it is is that I mean, like all taxonomies, it's a very particular picture of education.

00:40:27.530 --> 00:40:34.041
It's a way of looking at teaching and learning that centers on, in this case, performance as the sole benchmark of quality.

00:40:34.041 --> 00:40:43.992
So, like teaching and learning, in this taxonomy it consists of like discrete, automatable units like question solving, error correction, material creation.

00:40:43.992 --> 00:40:50.191
I don't think any teacher would describe their job as just question solving, error correction and materials creation.

00:40:50.191 --> 00:40:51.244
There's much more to it.

00:40:51.244 --> 00:40:54.106
Right, it doesn't capture the full grammar of educational activities.

00:40:54.106 --> 00:41:13.753
It doesn't capture the lived context in which those activities gain meaning, which I think is a particularly unique boundary for large language models in that while they're doing this kind of broad statistical modeling of language, they don't have kind of the context in which parts of language gain meaning in context, right.

00:41:13.753 --> 00:41:22.550
So some certain words and phrases might mean different things to teachers than it would to say, like someone who is not in the field.

00:41:22.550 --> 00:41:31.385
For example, the word taxonomy itself right for a teacher it evokes ideas of like bloom's taxonomy or um marzona's taxonomy.

00:41:31.385 --> 00:41:39.445
But if you say taxonomy to um a biologist, right, they might think of like the taxonomy of different animals, right, we're almost.

00:41:39.445 --> 00:41:42.833
For example, that's the taxonomy of creatures, biological things.

00:41:42.833 --> 00:41:44.525
Hummel, was that?

00:41:44.525 --> 00:41:49.704
I muddled through that, okay, I had a science reference and I want to make sure it's only a bonehead.

00:41:49.704 --> 00:41:53.987
So, like in general, I think it's not a critique of the paper.

00:41:53.987 --> 00:41:57.749
I think they did an admirable job with what they did.

00:41:57.749 --> 00:42:04.152
But I think it shows something that the field itself views education.

00:42:04.633 --> 00:42:25.954
When I say the field itself, right, the broad swath of AI research, ai tooling provided to teachers very much treats teaching as this kind of set of tasks that can be almost automated away, so tools for solving problems, generating questions, creating materials, but those actions themselves they don't carry meaning just because you did them right.

00:42:25.954 --> 00:42:27.646
They carry meaning in how you deploy them.

00:42:27.646 --> 00:42:35.733
A good question is only really a good question when it engages that student in meaning making in the classroom At the proper time.

00:42:35.733 --> 00:42:43.313
A follow-up question at the proper time A follow-up question only gains meaning when you ask that follow-up question again at the proper time, at the proper place to the right student.

00:42:43.313 --> 00:42:48.673
That's when that question gains meaning, because otherwise it's just sitting around and not really doing anything.

00:42:48.673 --> 00:42:50.983
And I worry about the general.

00:42:50.983 --> 00:42:55.353
The taxonomy is technically accurate.

00:42:55.353 --> 00:42:56.565
I think these tools are out there.

00:42:56.565 --> 00:43:01.026
There are tools for question solving and question creation, but that's not what's important.

00:43:01.026 --> 00:43:03.570
Necessarily the drafting of the materials are.

00:43:03.570 --> 00:43:11.630
But it's why you ask the questions how we correct students when we guide students, what it means for something to be understood.

00:43:12.221 --> 00:43:16.161
Large language model has no conception of any of these things because it has no conception of anything.

00:43:16.643 --> 00:43:20.913
So when you're working with an AI, you shouldn't think of it as a thought partner.

00:43:20.913 --> 00:43:21.981
It's not really that.

00:43:21.981 --> 00:43:28.931
What you're doing is you're playing a language game with a computer and you're trying to I'd say trick, but you're not really tricking it, because it doesn't have intentionality either.

00:43:28.931 --> 00:43:37.663
What you're trying to do is just select your words carefully so you put it in this language game, so it repeats back language that looks like high quality instruction.

00:43:37.663 --> 00:43:50.931
It doesn't understand high quality instruction, but we can trick it with language such that what it returns appears to be that Now, that can be hollow, that can be thin, that can be factually inaccurate if you're not taking proper precautions.

00:43:50.931 --> 00:43:59.556
But even if you take quote unquote proper precautions and I can dive into what those are you're still not going to completely eliminate hallucinations from AI responses.

00:43:59.556 --> 00:44:00.056
You can't.

00:44:00.056 --> 00:44:02.177
They're in a form of the system.

00:44:02.177 --> 00:44:09.802
They're a unique, emergent property of the probabilistic mapping of language in response to inputs.

00:44:09.802 --> 00:44:12.346
You will always have some level of hallucination.

00:44:13.282 --> 00:44:16.907
There's no the teacher's expertise.

00:44:16.907 --> 00:44:23.224
There is no other thing that can replace that, and that's what we build our system on.

00:44:24.467 --> 00:44:29.349
Yeah, no and that's something, oh, and I kind of wanted to add a little bit to what you're saying.

00:44:29.349 --> 00:44:34.492
I know it came up a little bit in the chat a while back that you were talking about, like you know, chatbots.

00:44:34.492 --> 00:44:50.023
And you know, if you put IDK, idk, idk, of course are we talking about, you know, just that exposure to the right answers and just correcting.

00:44:50.023 --> 00:44:51.164
You know, are we missing out on so many more things?

00:44:51.164 --> 00:44:59.713
And obviously you've mentioned a lot of things you know and, like Thomas H, you just said right now that you know there are some things that the AI cannot replace that teachers can do, as opposed to, like you mentioned, very probabilistic answers.

00:44:59.813 --> 00:45:15.162
And I know, back in episode 324, I believe, I had Charlie Myers who was on here and said you know, it's pretty much just a data set, like in a matrix, that you know you're putting in an answer and then you know it's just going to give you something back.

00:45:15.162 --> 00:45:28.595
You know it's a mathematical equation, but the way that he said it and I don't know how you think about this too but he said you know, if we were being completely honest, that when we are putting a chatbot in front of a student and it said, hey, I'm just a chatbot.

00:45:28.595 --> 00:45:38.411
I have no context about you, I don't know anything about you, but you're giving me this question and I'm going to give you a question without you know whatever it is that I know and I can crank out.

00:45:38.411 --> 00:45:43.396
You know, is this really what you're putting in front of your students and what is your thought process in doing that?

00:45:43.396 --> 00:45:47.380
You know.

00:45:47.380 --> 00:45:48.985
So I think that that's something that we need to think about.

00:45:49.005 --> 00:45:57.391
As I know, thomas H you mentioned it with a couple of platforms that may say, hey, you know, go ahead and talk to Abraham Lincoln, but how well is that information going to come in?

00:45:57.391 --> 00:46:07.755
How accurate is it going to be, and is there still room for the teacher to be able to go ahead and make any corrections and make sure that they vet the information properly?

00:46:07.755 --> 00:46:21.418
And so those are just kind of the things that I think about, too, when students are have access to, you know, an LLM, whether it's a persona that they're talking to, historical figure, or if it's just the LLM itself.

00:46:21.418 --> 00:46:24.686
So I want to ask you, you know what are some of the challenges?

00:46:24.686 --> 00:46:36.730
Thomas H, I'll go with you, like this past year and just this past year, we'll focus on this, because I know it's been a long road, but in this past year, what have been some of the major challenges that you've seen within your school?

00:46:36.730 --> 00:46:41.613
You know as far as teachers using AI within their classrooms.

00:46:42.436 --> 00:46:45.463
Yeah, the biggest challenge is that we don't have time to even learn AI.

00:46:45.463 --> 00:46:47.409
I went this whole year.

00:46:47.409 --> 00:46:56.671
I planned for an eighth grade class that never even hired an eighth grade teacher, so we just had rotating subs the entire year, and that's just the reality of most schools.

00:46:56.671 --> 00:46:58.940
I think like 70 percent of schools have a vacancy.

00:46:58.940 --> 00:47:08.365
That's available and it's hard to get to a spot where you're thriving if you're worried about surviving, and that's where most schools are at, most public schools are at right now.

00:47:08.559 --> 00:47:12.932
So my school has done zero AI policy.

00:47:12.932 --> 00:47:30.083
Cbs tried to come in and film us and like film me and Thomas whenever we were first started with EduAid me and Thomas whenever we were first started with EduAid and they denied CBS from coming in and doing an interview because they were so scared about the reputation of AI and what that means for our local community and things.

00:47:30.083 --> 00:47:33.650
And so I'm on our AI committee.

00:47:33.650 --> 00:47:44.195
We've issued some guidance where now every single assignment, a teacher has to dictate the amount of AI that the student is allowed to use on it.

00:47:44.195 --> 00:47:49.701
I'm not sure that that necessarily covers everything, but it does start to frame the world.

00:47:49.701 --> 00:47:53.750
It doesn't allow us to hide from the fact that this technology is here.

00:47:53.750 --> 00:47:57.847
So maybe, if it's an essay, I'll tell my students this is a five.

00:47:57.847 --> 00:47:59.831
You cannot use any AI on it at all.

00:47:59.831 --> 00:48:02.244
If you do, that would be considered cheating or something like that.

00:48:02.244 --> 00:48:04.851
That's the idea with the guidelines of the ai.

00:48:04.851 --> 00:48:09.163
But uh, my school is so far behind and fawns.

00:48:09.182 --> 00:48:18.969
I'll even tell you this we just did a maryland summit over outside of dc and baltimore, and I was the only person from my school district to attend the summit.

00:48:18.969 --> 00:48:22.427
And not only that, I was one of three people from the entire general area in which we live that attended the summit.

00:48:22.427 --> 00:48:25.990
And not only that, I was one of three people from the entire general area in which we live that attended the summit.

00:48:25.990 --> 00:48:41.023
And so, to me, I'm a big believer that this is going to continue to create this digital divide and it's only going to amplify it because, like, people aren't even like and I'm not trying to be a hater here but like, the school districts where I live don't even care.

00:48:41.305 --> 00:48:44.887
They don't even care to do what's best for the students, they don't even care about this information.

00:48:44.887 --> 00:48:50.927
They're just trying to hire enough teachers to staff their building and that's their number one priority.

00:48:50.927 --> 00:48:56.561
So you know where I'm from and where I'm dealing with it like on a personal level.

00:48:56.561 --> 00:48:58.104
Who knows?

00:48:58.104 --> 00:49:07.675
I mean, we have it's the Wild West still of AI and it's year three, so there's no plans in my school district at all to guide or to do anything.

00:49:07.675 --> 00:49:26.231
In fact, they actually bought Turnitin and I had to throw a huge fit because nobody even read any of the data about how those things work, whether they can actually identify AI or anything like that, and so you know, I live in that kind of system and there's many like that out there.

00:49:26.753 --> 00:49:47.108
Yeah, you know and it's very interesting just to kind of go back to that that you mentioned that there are many schools that really, at this point, yes, the conversations are kind of being had, there's that summer slide, but you know what, now that I'm coming back, it's like I got to worry to make sure that I do have a teacher in a classroom and so on, and so that's where those priorities are.

00:49:47.108 --> 00:49:50.931
Now my thing is, and I'm going to ask you this and then I kind of want to go back.

00:49:50.931 --> 00:49:56.987
We'll go back into some of the great updates and new things that you're bringing out to EDU8.

00:49:56.987 --> 00:50:39.009
As founders, you know, and getting just an honest answer from you, you know, being at ISTE and seeing, you know, kind of like the big five companies that are out there slowly, that are that were at ISTE, that are kind of slowly just being a predominant name or very well-known name as a founder, you know, and as much effort as they put into this, sometimes I feel like, you know, are they a little bit out of touch and think that this is a perfect utopia, that everybody should have access to AI, and they really don't consider, you know, what is happening here, like you described, thomas H, and so I kind of want to know from you, you know, as EduAID founders, what are your thoughts here?

00:50:39.028 --> 00:50:42.297
You know, as, as EduAID founders, what are your thoughts here?

00:50:42.297 --> 00:50:57.382
You know, because, again, I see that people are all in and and in in our bubble and the bubble that I was in this last weekend, I feel like everybody's like no, we all have it, we all have it, everybody should have it, everybody should be using it, everybody should have access.

00:50:57.382 --> 00:51:08.050
And I'm like do you not know that other school districts have other issues and bigger problems, and you know teacher shortages and all of that, but the push is go, go, go, go, go, ai, ai.

00:51:08.050 --> 00:51:18.233
So I want to ask you how do you guys keep your feet grounded, because I feel like you guys are very well grounded, you know, and, kind of, because of Thomas H, you're still in the classroom.

00:51:18.233 --> 00:51:19.947
So, thomas T, I'll go with you.

00:51:19.947 --> 00:51:22.166
How does that work for you both?

00:51:22.166 --> 00:51:23.601
What do you see?

00:51:23.601 --> 00:51:34.467
And how do you guys just kind of, you know, understand that man, we ourselves, as founders are, have some barriers to overcome to make sure that we can help teachers?

00:51:35.829 --> 00:51:49.715
yeah, I mean one area where we're particularly lucky is that thomas humble is obstinate in his desire to stay in the classroom, like will not come on the edu-A full time, despite the pleas for more assistance.

00:51:49.715 --> 00:51:58.579
But I'm kidding, he likes to stay in the classroom and we respect this decision precisely because one he sees the application in action.

00:51:58.579 --> 00:52:00.164
It's one thing to gather feedback.

00:52:00.164 --> 00:52:05.546
It's one thing to have users send you know videos of their usage of the tool to you.

00:52:05.546 --> 00:52:31.510
It's it's one thing to do studies, and but if you I mean it's something that I even find myself missing now that I'm no longer in the classroom was like stepping into that building in the morning and working with students and like maybe I'm getting too far away into thinking about like philosophy of education and the science of learning and things like this, because on the day, on day to day, it's like how much was that crossing my mind while I was in the classroom.

00:52:31.671 --> 00:52:49.329
You know, how much was um, I don't know, just to pick out some random like uh tech tool platforms that were around, like how much was Kealo, or or, or nuzella or, um, I don't know, canva at the top of my mind on, I didn't, the tool was a means to an end, right?

00:52:49.329 --> 00:52:51.762
I'm concerned about my student behaviors.

00:52:51.762 --> 00:52:53.508
I'm concerned about my classroom management.

00:52:53.508 --> 00:52:56.646
I'm concerned about reaching the, the 25 students in front of me.

00:52:56.646 --> 00:53:11.086
I'm concerned that when I say something, I think an action as a teacher that's going to set off 25 minds in different reactions which will then bounce off of each other and cause even more reactions like teaching is a very messy and chaotic thing.

00:53:11.086 --> 00:53:13.932
I mean, my classroom is really well run.

00:53:13.972 --> 00:53:28.604
I don't want to sound like I had, like was struggling to manage my classroom, like I had routines and structures from day one and like had that down, but what I'm saying is it's very easy if you are not in the classroom to be removed from the day-to-day struggle and context of the teacher.

00:53:28.604 --> 00:53:33.385
And if you were removed from the day-to-day context, that the means of life as a teacher.

00:53:33.385 --> 00:53:37.280
You don't have that same grammar, you're not speaking the same language, so to speak.

00:53:37.280 --> 00:53:41.405
You're kind of talking past each other, which is very common, I think, in think, in the world today.

00:53:41.405 --> 00:53:52.036
So it's like technologists, even most well-intentioned individuals, have this kind of just grammatical gap from the daily experience of the educator.

00:53:52.296 --> 00:53:53.097
And that's very tough.

00:53:53.097 --> 00:53:56.769
I mean, that's something that you're going to see reflected in AI outputs as well.

00:53:56.769 --> 00:53:59.742
I mean the day-to-day interactions between a teacher and student.

00:53:59.742 --> 00:54:00.985
They're not documented.

00:54:00.985 --> 00:54:10.296
I mean, there are plenty of blogs out there that maybe talk about this and it might be in the training data, but it's not a thing that is so prominent and so discernible.

00:54:10.296 --> 00:54:14.932
Also, learning is, for all intents and purposes, invisible.

00:54:14.932 --> 00:54:21.686
It's not something that we can see, it's not something that you can point to and like it happens internally in the student's mind, mind.

00:54:21.726 --> 00:54:24.152
So we have all these proxies that take place for it, right?

00:54:24.152 --> 00:54:27.099
Um, some good, some not so good.

00:54:27.099 --> 00:54:32.992
Like when I first started teaching, uh, the school I was teaching at with hummel admittedly had terrible proxies.

00:54:32.992 --> 00:54:38.101
It's like, did you have your learning objective and success criteria on the board and did you refer to them?

00:54:38.101 --> 00:54:44.512
Like, well, this is a proxy for quality, but how does this in any way relate to real and meaningful learning on the part of the student?

00:54:44.512 --> 00:54:44.974
It doesn't.

00:54:45.519 --> 00:54:50.413
So it's like I worry about the proxies taken by those who are not in the classroom.

00:54:50.413 --> 00:54:55.932
I worry about kind of having that contextual barrier where you're not really speaking the same language.

00:54:55.932 --> 00:55:02.971
I also worry that education is incredibly faddish, right, we like to repackage things and say it's something brand new.

00:55:02.971 --> 00:55:12.728
It's like okay, discovery learning, inquiry-based learning, self-guided learning, like all of these things are essentially the same thing, just like some slight PR changes.

00:55:12.728 --> 00:55:21.123
It's like, so, even at that level, like we can't even get on the same page of what we're talking about from one school to the next or one classroom to the next.

00:55:21.123 --> 00:55:22.306
What one of what we're talking about?

00:55:22.306 --> 00:55:24.672
From one school to the next or one classroom to the next, what one teacher might call?

00:55:24.692 --> 00:55:26.055
a specific method another teacher will call another.

00:55:26.055 --> 00:55:27.238
Sorry, there's a terrible storm outside.

00:55:27.238 --> 00:55:31.730
I'm getting a lot of background noise.

00:55:31.730 --> 00:55:32.713
So I mean I said a lot there.

00:55:35.460 --> 00:55:52.045
If I had to like summarize this down to like the prime concerns, it's like very easy to find yourself in your own kind of language game, your own bubble, so to speak, and very easy to then like assume you're talking about the same thing as other folks, just to realize that you're that you're not right.

00:55:52.581 --> 00:55:54.288
That's a great tip about marriage as well.

00:55:54.288 --> 00:56:00.083
It's not the fights that you have, it's when you think you're in agreement, without actually ever having the conversation to make sure that you are.

00:56:00.083 --> 00:56:10.528
You're just assuming the other person has the same expectations, needs, wants and desires, and it's like the needs and wants and desires and theory of mind of a technologist will not be the same as a teacher.

00:56:10.528 --> 00:56:13.269
So it also helps that we don't live in a tech hub either.

00:56:13.269 --> 00:56:14.867
Like I live in Annapolis, maryland.

00:56:14.867 --> 00:56:18.811
I go to the coffee shop by St John College, I talk to teachers.

00:56:18.811 --> 00:56:24.865
I'm very much, my feet are on the ground and kind of removed from the conference scene.

00:56:24.865 --> 00:56:32.851
So when I go to something like an ISTE or ASUGSB, it's like whoa, this is a whole new world from what I'm accustomed to in Maryland.

00:56:33.901 --> 00:56:34.443
And Thomas H.

00:56:34.443 --> 00:56:36.268
I'll go with you too because I want to get your feedback.

00:56:36.268 --> 00:56:46.148
I know being said that you were the only one in your school, I mean, and I went to ISTE this year and it was my second ISTE, but this year I got to participate a little bit more.

00:56:46.148 --> 00:56:58.470
But it just seems like sometimes I think, like man, like this is just a bubble that's here and we kind of lose all sense and notion of reality of how things can really be at other school districts.

00:56:58.470 --> 00:57:02.108
So I want to ask you that you know how do you keep your feet ground?

00:57:02.108 --> 00:57:06.927
Obviously, I think it's just because of the experience that you're still there in the classroom.

00:57:06.947 --> 00:57:19.461
But tell me your thoughts and you know it's super weird, because tech is an abundance industry where they just make tons of money, have tons of money, have all kinds of funding, and you know, money is never an issue with tech, but then education money is always an issue.

00:57:19.461 --> 00:57:23.684
Money is never an issue with tech, but then education money is always an issue, and it's a scarcity industry.

00:57:23.684 --> 00:57:33.068
And so it's funny how, you know, we see the difference between these two things, and the bridge between those two could not be any further.

00:57:33.068 --> 00:58:02.818
Their product would be totally different than what it actually is, because you would have a better understanding of what it actually means to be grounded in the classroom and providing instruction, being forward, thinking about it Right, like I can't just teach a class on Wednesday and not know where that's going on Thursday or Friday, and those kind of things.

00:58:02.818 --> 00:58:04.351
Like just that whole mindset is totally missed in education.

00:58:04.351 --> 00:58:05.992
Or is it missed in the ed tech department of education?

00:58:05.992 --> 00:58:16.418
And there's just if you think about where we've been for the last 15 years, we've only seen a decrease in the quality of our education and the outcomes of our students.

00:58:16.418 --> 00:58:26.623
And yet everybody who has a tech product tells you that it's the best thing that's ever come to be and it's going to save all the problems, but the general trend of education is heading in the complete opposite direction.

00:58:27.124 --> 00:58:52.077
And so that goes to tell me that either people are a uh, you know, they believe their products and they believe that they can solve the world's problems, or, b that they're lying and it's just disingenuous and that they're trying to make money off the backs of teachers and students and you know I don't want to put that on anybody, but that's the reality of it is that if you're going to make these promises and you don't keep them, there are consequences to it.

00:58:52.077 --> 00:59:04.742
And I'll give you one here is that the Gallup poll that just came out said that teachers are saving six hours a week with AI, but when all these products came out, it was 10 plus hours a week.

00:59:04.742 --> 00:59:18.826
And so my challenge to these people and to anybody thinking about this serious if they come up 40 percent short on the student department 40 percent they come up 40 percent on their expectations or their guarantees or their promises short.

00:59:18.826 --> 00:59:22.396
Are you OK with that, with that happening to a student?

00:59:22.396 --> 00:59:30.893
I don't know why we're OK with that happening to teachers, and it just doesn't make sense.

00:59:30.893 --> 00:59:34.322
And if we're not going to do what's best for teachers with tech, then you truly don't care about the students either.

00:59:34.322 --> 00:59:37.653
And that's really concerning um, and I think that's how we stay grounded.

00:59:37.733 --> 00:59:40.621
Honestly, it's like we never the framing and intentionality.

00:59:40.621 --> 00:59:41.451
We've never said that.

00:59:41.451 --> 00:59:43.476
We never said this is going to save you xyz.

00:59:43.476 --> 00:59:46.744
We just said it's going to save you time and create higher quality lessons.

00:59:46.744 --> 00:59:52.525
And that's what all of our users always say, um, and so it's really interesting, but there's no repercussions for it, fawn.

00:59:52.525 --> 00:59:57.244
So you know, you could go out there with your own ed tech company say you're going to make every student get 100.

00:59:57.244 --> 01:00:01.235
Everybody buys it, and that doesn't come true.

01:00:01.235 --> 01:00:41.300
There's no repercussions to it at all, because the thing that's happened with the tech department of educational technology is that there's so much money poured into the growth of these companies, where growth is the only thing that matters, but the quality does not seem to follow that growth and, if anything, that's just going to continue us on the trend of the last 15 years, and I think that's a shame for AI, because this is the most revolutionary technology that's ever come about in my lifetime and for us to just, you know, continue with false claims or marketing schemes.

01:00:41.300 --> 01:00:43.443
It's just, it's really upsetting sometimes.

01:00:43.824 --> 01:01:00.119
I mean it doesn't help that the whole enterprise of teaching and learning is incredibly complex and messy and how that process works doesn't map on neatly to any one tool or application.

01:01:00.119 --> 01:01:11.724
So when you frame an application or tool as a general solution to a lot of problems it becomes disingenuous in that there are no general solutions to all of the problems in teaching.

01:01:11.724 --> 01:01:23.055
There are particular contextual solutions based on the particular group of students in front of you or the particular kind of context of the school that you're working in, and it's hard to generalize that.

01:01:23.055 --> 01:01:34.878
We love to systematize and generalize it and kind of have these broad taxonomies or frameworks for kind of viewing everything through that lens, and those lenses run into more trouble than they're worth.

01:01:34.878 --> 01:01:45.316
Honestly, every tool should be like it's useful in these particular contexts and that should be a fine claim to make, but it seems it's not the claim that leads to hype and growth, so it's hard to claim it all.

01:01:45.396 --> 01:01:49.463
It's hard, though, because the whole ecosystem of ed tech, right.

01:01:49.463 --> 01:01:57.469
Where's the governing body that is checking the quality of magic schools, tools, eduades, brisk, diff it?

01:01:57.469 --> 01:02:11.380
There is none, and the only ones that that you do, you have to pay to get, have them do that, and so, right, it's like there isn't an honest perspective on ed tech that puts it in front of the educators, um, and I think that that's wrong.

01:02:11.461 --> 01:02:15.500
So I mean the question also comes around what are the measurement criteria themselves?

01:02:15.500 --> 01:02:15.880
Like?

01:02:15.880 --> 01:02:29.686
It's okay, so you record time saving, but it was like time saving to to what it time-saving in that a novice teacher is bypassing the hard cognitive work of doing and planning instruction.

01:02:29.686 --> 01:02:31.738
Are they losing intentionality?

01:02:31.738 --> 01:02:39.601
I mean, this is something that we also need to consider If we're worried about skills loss from over-reliance on AI at the student level.

01:02:39.601 --> 01:02:51.710
We need to stop pretending that adults also don't have brains that react to stimuli, and not the same way as students, obviously, but in dynamic and interesting ways that it's not immediately apparent.

01:02:51.710 --> 01:03:04.570
It's like OK, so if you kind of outsource your upper cognitive functioning in terms of lesson planning and instructional design, maybe your product, you have the product, yet state you have the lesson, you have the materials.

01:03:04.570 --> 01:03:05.552
Product, you have the product, the at stake.

01:03:05.552 --> 01:03:06.554
Like you have the lesson, you have the materials.

01:03:06.574 --> 01:03:14.302
But if I was, you can envision a study where you have let's take 100 teachers, right, you put 50 of them in the control group.

01:03:14.302 --> 01:03:20.951
They're just doing straight lesson planning, human to human, maybe collaborative planning, they're just planning in a vacuum with traditional materials.

01:03:20.951 --> 01:03:25.958
Um, maybe give another one, another teacher, just access to basic search functionality.

01:03:25.958 --> 01:03:30.806
Another group and then your other group would be teachers using generative AI tools.

01:03:30.806 --> 01:03:35.820
If you were to say you need to return x, y and z materials, you specify it.

01:03:35.820 --> 01:03:36.722
I want a lesson plan.

01:03:36.722 --> 01:03:39.055
I want the materials for instruction to go with it.

01:03:40.358 --> 01:03:49.584
Once you have all those materials, if you were to ask each one of those teachers in those groups to explain their lesson to you, which group do you think would be able to do that best?

01:03:49.584 --> 01:04:07.869
And is it more important than that we create materials of instruction or that teachers still have that level of explainability where they understand at the content level, at the pedagogical level, what it is that they're doing, why they're doing it and when it's appropriate to augment it and to change it they're doing, why they're doing it and when it's appropriate to augment it and to change it.

01:04:07.869 --> 01:04:11.173
Over-reliance, I think, will always be an issue.

01:04:11.173 --> 01:04:16.811
Verification and prompting, I mean all of these kind of converge, maybe at the worst time too, with educational outcomes being at kind of historical lows.

01:04:16.811 --> 01:04:23.731
Maybe they're bouncing back from the worst parts of COVID, but still a lot of concerns out the open there?

01:04:23.751 --> 01:04:25.753
Yeah, no, most definitely, I think, you guys hit still a lot of concerns out in the open there.

01:04:25.773 --> 01:04:26.235
Yeah, no, most definitely.

01:04:26.235 --> 01:04:53.215
I think you guys hit on a lot of great things, and one thing that I will say, and just the fact that you guys are just so well-grounded really, we don't see you at the ISTEs, we don't see you at TCEAs and we don't see you in all that but just the fact that you're still very well known and being very well recognized for the work that you're doing and because of the help that you bring to others, and just the pedagogy behind this.

01:04:53.215 --> 01:04:59.744
It's not just tech first and that's one thing that I really enjoy and speaking with you all that it's not about the tech first.

01:04:59.744 --> 01:05:15.162
It's what can I do for the teacher first, help them, like you said, having those levels of explainability, not being too over-reliant, but just reliant enough to where they can enhance what they are already doing, still be able to work with the students and still be able to share all those great things with them.

01:05:15.162 --> 01:05:16.777
So that's something that's huge there.

01:05:17.250 --> 01:05:26.230
So, as we kind of start wrapping up, though, before I want to talk about some of the newer updates, and I know that I've been seeing a lot of that on social media as well.

01:05:26.230 --> 01:05:28.979
So we'll go ahead and start with Thomas H.

01:05:28.979 --> 01:05:33.056
Tell me a little bit about through that teacher lens and mindset.

01:05:33.056 --> 01:05:40.046
You know what are some of the updates there that the educators should be thrilled about that have come out through on your platform.

01:05:40.369 --> 01:05:40.630
Yeah.

01:05:40.630 --> 01:05:44.032
So I don't know if Thomas Thompson would frame it this way, but I'm going to frame it this way.

01:05:44.032 --> 01:05:58.740
It's that we've done a good job at enhancing our graphic organizers and our games and these are things that teachers typically would go to Teachers Pay Teachers for because somebody else has done it at a certain quality or it's going to save you time or X, y, z.

01:05:58.740 --> 01:06:09.425
But we believe that our prompting and the quality in which we're putting out for those things is better than, if not comparable to, the best teacher pay teacher stuff.

01:06:09.425 --> 01:06:16.351
And we're doing it obviously at a fraction or no cost and I'm really, really excited about that.

01:06:16.351 --> 01:06:27.878
It's like, how can we allow teachers to create content that is specific for those students, specific for lessons, and that is reaching those deeper goals or just reaching the goals of the lesson or the standard?

01:06:27.878 --> 01:06:32.802
So super stoked about those two things the graphic organizers and the games.

01:06:34.911 --> 01:06:35.835
There's this game we have.

01:06:35.835 --> 01:06:36.697
It's tic-tac-toe.

01:06:36.697 --> 01:06:43.610
Obviously, everybody knows how to play it, but I'm so excited to get my students doing it as a review whereas I'm going to give them questions.

01:06:43.610 --> 01:06:58.282
I've already started making stuff for the next year, like on cells and stuff like that's how I start the year but like instead of me doing like a five question review, I'm going to give them their own, like them and a partner their own separate tic-tac-toe game with like all the nine spaces with review questions and stuff.

01:06:58.282 --> 01:07:11.153
Like I cannot wait to see how I can start to gamify my lessons and just make them that much more engaging, rather than I want to take out all of the me in the front of the classroom and put it on the students and the partners and like.

01:07:11.153 --> 01:07:18.465
That's where I'm going with it this year and I think that Eduway is going to allow me to do that excellent Thomas, thomas T, how about yourself?

01:07:18.505 --> 01:07:19.630
tell me about all that excitement?

01:07:21.032 --> 01:07:24.079
yeah, I mean, basically I've been sitting on this binder.

01:07:24.079 --> 01:07:26.344
This is mr claire's graphic organizers.

01:07:26.344 --> 01:07:30.701
I picked up my senior year of high school when I first started thinking about teaching.

01:07:30.701 --> 01:07:34.675
It's like when I first launched eduator, like these graphic organizers.

01:07:34.675 --> 01:07:43.682
I use them almost every day in the classroom, some form of them right, being able to lay out materials in a very visual, structured way.

01:07:44.413 --> 01:07:48.556
When gendered of ai first came out, it was the streaming walls of text, but that got old pretty quick.

01:07:48.556 --> 01:07:52.597
So we moved into the structured outputs, graphic organizers particularly.

01:07:52.597 --> 01:07:54.753
They were echoing each other.

01:07:54.753 --> 01:07:56.476
Just because we're excited about it, we just put it out.

01:07:56.476 --> 01:07:59.264
But one thing to note on those.

01:07:59.264 --> 01:08:09.280
It's like here's one version of Mr Clare's change analysis worksheet but then like here's another version of it, which is the few slight alterations and tweaks.

01:08:09.280 --> 01:08:10.996
Here's another version of it.

01:08:10.996 --> 01:08:20.341
Right, there were always different versions of those same graphic organizers floating around his class, depending on the group, depending on the particulars of the context of the students.

01:08:20.909 --> 01:08:28.921
So we built these such that there's a bunch of these like one-click toggles where you can add a collaboration activity to the beginning of the Venn diagram.

01:08:28.921 --> 01:08:41.771
Or maybe you have a Venn diagram, you add a third circle, it will just kind of automatically refactor itself based on your content, that you've input, but like they'll do it dynamically, so it's all one-click differentiation, all simple toggles.

01:08:41.771 --> 01:08:46.976
You can add, you know, the retrieval question set to your mark in the text exercise.

01:08:46.976 --> 01:08:53.324
Or you can change it to a 3-2-1 for writing prep, where you're putting out three vocabulary words that you didn't understand, two sentences.

01:08:53.324 --> 01:08:55.667
You would rewrite what the central claim was.

01:08:55.667 --> 01:09:08.586
Very fast, differentiation of multiple copies of materials and like a fraction of the time it would take me to create one beforehand would have been very powerful.

01:09:08.605 --> 01:09:14.521
When I was in the Kotak classroom working with, you know, 15 students with IEPs, and I needed to do a lot of that differentiation work.

01:09:14.521 --> 01:09:22.443
I mean, it's no wonder that EduAid started that year when I was doing all of that work right, trying to do the differentiation piece.

01:09:22.443 --> 01:09:26.078
So that's what got me really excited about organizers work, right, you're trying to do the differentiation piece.

01:09:26.078 --> 01:09:27.662
So that's what got me really excited about organizers, the community response.

01:09:27.662 --> 01:09:30.086
We couldn't be happier with it, a lot of excitement and interest.

01:09:30.591 --> 01:09:35.690
And then I mean our roadmap for the next few months has been totally dictated by the community, right?

01:09:35.690 --> 01:09:47.274
Folks coming online saying I love the organizers, but let's see some argument maps, let's see flow charts, let's see storyboards, uh, analogy diagrams, the cornell note-taking formats, concept maps and so on.

01:09:47.274 --> 01:09:58.753
So it's like now we have our playful like we tested the, uh, the general idea and, yes, teachers, like the um graphic organizers, won't interact with them, so we'll continue to build it out.

01:09:58.753 --> 01:10:02.082
And then I mean back-end stuff that teachers can't see.

01:10:02.082 --> 01:10:15.935
Right, these new evaluator tools that we have our hands on being able to really like on a very fine-tuned level, get a look at what our outputs are and how we can tweak them and how we can continue to improve the end output on EduAid is also very exciting.

01:10:16.395 --> 01:10:16.737
It's fun.

01:10:16.898 --> 01:10:17.841
Like what else.

01:10:17.841 --> 01:10:22.873
I get to wake up in the morning, I get to talk to other educators, folks working in education they're educators, folks working in education.

01:10:22.873 --> 01:10:24.917
I get to do research, I get to do experiments.

01:10:24.917 --> 01:10:25.738
It's truly a blessing.

01:10:26.297 --> 01:10:28.520
That's fantastic, it's stressful sometimes.

01:10:29.042 --> 01:10:32.765
Yeah, no, but it's fantastic the work that you're doing and just to continue to do that.

01:10:32.765 --> 01:10:36.533
And, again, the way that you put community first too.

01:10:36.533 --> 01:10:48.944
I mean I know that there are many other platforms out there that always say, yeah, community first, and I know to some extent extent, but just the fact that you guys really do do this and it's community first and you really take that into account.

01:10:48.944 --> 01:10:54.712
And I know thomas h being at the school too, I'm sure he hears it from his teachers like, hey, how about trying to add a little bit of this or a little bit of that or something?

01:10:54.712 --> 01:11:04.740
I mean, it's not always that you get to work with a co-founder of an ai platform and then you can give a suggestion right then and there, and, and that's something that's fantastic.

01:11:04.740 --> 01:11:05.582
So that's huge.

01:11:05.582 --> 01:11:07.556
But, gentlemen, thank you so much.

01:11:07.556 --> 01:11:09.416
I really appreciate you being on the show.

01:11:09.416 --> 01:11:10.179
Thank you so much.

01:11:10.179 --> 01:11:17.739
Also, from the bottom of my heart, my sincerest thanks for being just an amazing supporter of my EdTech life and the work that we're doing here.

01:11:17.739 --> 01:11:28.143
Because, again, if it wasn't for platforms like yourself and just not just platforms, but just humans like yourself, yourself and just not just platforms, but just humans like yourself, human beings that I consider friends like yourself.

01:11:28.143 --> 01:11:34.090
Thomas Hummel, thomas Thompson, thank you so much for everything that you've done for this show and just that we continue to bring these great conversations.

01:11:34.090 --> 01:11:37.180
So I really appreciate everything that you're doing and for all our listeners.

01:11:37.180 --> 01:11:41.359
Please make sure that you follow these fine gentlemen on LinkedIn.

01:11:41.359 --> 01:11:44.015
I promise you they always do some great posts.

01:11:44.015 --> 01:11:50.028
But please make sure that you check out EduAid also as well, and of course, those links will be there in the show notes.

01:11:50.328 --> 01:11:59.095
But before we wrap up, I know we always end the show with these last couple of questions and it's interesting to hear now from our four-time guest.

01:11:59.095 --> 01:12:02.202
I know every appearance he's had a different answer.

01:12:02.202 --> 01:12:03.916
Thomas H2, I don't know.

01:12:03.916 --> 01:12:10.759
I'm always anxious to hear your answers to these questions, so we'll go ahead and start with Thomas H first.

01:12:10.759 --> 01:12:11.542
This first one.

01:12:11.542 --> 01:12:17.279
As we know, every superhero has a weakness, so Kryptonite was Superman's weakness.

01:12:17.279 --> 01:12:28.394
So I want to ask you right now, in the current state of AI or it could be in education in general, it could be either one or both what would you say is your current edu kryptonite?

01:12:29.074 --> 01:12:34.984
Yeah, I would say just, you know the fact that I'm still a teacher.

01:12:34.984 --> 01:12:37.055
I just think that this one hits home a little bit.

01:12:37.055 --> 01:12:56.579
But just trusting in the teachers as professionals, I think that that's something that's been taken away from us for a trend for a while, and I think I see that in the tech as well been taken away from us for a trend for a while, and I think I see that in the tech as well coming through is we just need to trust teachers in being the professionals and if you take you know, if you take the judgment of teachers away from them, that is only going to hurt education.

01:12:56.579 --> 01:13:02.684
And if you take the decision making away from the people that know the students the best, I think that that's bad for education.

01:13:02.684 --> 01:13:07.787
So I would say that that's my kry kryptonite is Just keep teachers with their power, and I think that's a good thing.

01:13:08.346 --> 01:13:16.886
Excellent, good answer, thomas.

01:13:16.905 --> 01:13:17.588
T what would your edu-kryptonite be?

01:13:17.588 --> 01:13:20.372
Currently, You're muted.

01:13:20.511 --> 01:13:23.034
I was trying to block out the storm.

01:13:23.034 --> 01:13:26.118
Maybe kryptonite might be the wrong word, but it's the thing.

01:13:26.118 --> 01:13:38.197
That's definitely a gap and I'm working really hard to get a sense of how we fill it, which is, we have all these general heuristics for how to do teaching well, space your practice and accept your problems, these kinds of things.

01:13:38.197 --> 01:13:44.378
How do you translate that into precise kind of adaptive systems that you can put out in front of teachers?

01:13:44.378 --> 01:13:47.538
So it's like I'm going to sound like a broken record here.

01:13:47.538 --> 01:13:53.841
Retrieval practice, interleaving, spacing how do you get those to interact dynamically and not just independently?

01:13:53.841 --> 01:13:56.038
I'm also just mimicking Carl Hendrick.

01:13:56.038 --> 01:13:57.735
You should go subscribe to his substack.

01:13:57.735 --> 01:13:59.510
The Learning Dispatch Him.

01:13:59.510 --> 01:14:03.822
Exploring the science of learning is a constant source of inspiration on our side.

01:14:03.822 --> 01:14:05.056
But yeah, how do you translate that?

01:14:05.056 --> 01:14:09.212
The problem that we started off trying to solve?

01:14:09.231 --> 01:14:10.335
is the problem that we're still wrestling with?

01:14:10.335 --> 01:14:11.237
Excellent, all right, great answer.

01:14:11.237 --> 01:14:12.840
Now I'm going to start with you, thomas t.

01:14:12.840 --> 01:14:16.556
What if you could have a billboard with anything on it?

01:14:16.556 --> 01:14:18.159
What would it be and why?

01:14:20.305 --> 01:14:25.199
um, I've had other answers that were a little pedantic, so let's go with something a little more fun.

01:14:25.199 --> 01:14:42.364
Um, hmm, maybe I'll just go with the quote I pulled for that sub stack I put out, which is uh, a picture held us captive and we could not get outside of it for it lay in language and language seemed to repeat it to us inexorably.

01:14:42.364 --> 01:14:44.414
I think that's a powerful reminder.

01:14:45.297 --> 01:14:46.721
All right, excellent, good.

01:14:46.721 --> 01:14:46.940
Quote.

01:14:46.940 --> 01:14:47.523
I love it to us inexorably.

01:14:47.542 --> 01:14:50.090
I think that's a powerful reminder All right, excellent, good quote I love it All right, thomas H, still pedantic, less fun.

01:14:50.090 --> 01:14:52.414
Sorry, couldn't think of a fun thing off the top of my head.

01:14:53.077 --> 01:14:55.271
Hey, it works, though it works, Thomas H.

01:14:55.271 --> 01:14:56.136
What would your billboard?

01:14:56.176 --> 01:14:59.920
say Join Edu8 Educators on Facebook.

01:15:06.010 --> 01:15:07.576
We're giving away $ hundred dollars every friday for the summer.

01:15:07.576 --> 01:15:08.199
That's what it is.

01:15:08.199 --> 01:15:08.460
There you go.

01:15:08.460 --> 01:15:08.822
Hey, that's it.

01:15:08.822 --> 01:15:09.645
Hey, that's a great billboard too.

01:15:09.645 --> 01:15:10.529
Sign me up for that too as well every time.

01:15:10.548 --> 01:15:11.672
Go ahead for real that join.

01:15:11.672 --> 01:15:15.431
Uh, we're giving away a hundred dollars to every to a teacher every friday for all summer.

01:15:15.431 --> 01:15:20.871
So that's kind of how we like to give back is just um, literally just give back to teachers.

01:15:21.493 --> 01:15:25.029
Excellent, no and it has been a thriving community there on Facebook.

01:15:25.029 --> 01:15:34.972
So please make sure that you join that Facebook group and I will make sure and give you all the links, all right, listeners, so you can make sure that you connect, join the Facebook group and all that great stuff, all right?

01:15:34.972 --> 01:15:37.720
Last question All right, so we'll start with Thomas H.

01:15:37.720 --> 01:15:42.060
Thomas H, if you could trade places with a single person for a day, who would that be and why?

01:15:42.060 --> 01:15:43.967
Wow, with a single person for a day, who would that be and why?

01:15:45.050 --> 01:16:02.902
Wow, if I could trade places with a single person for a day, I probably would trade places with Cristiano Ronaldo, maybe, just so I would know what it would be like to be great at soccer.

01:16:02.902 --> 01:16:08.300
I think I spent like the first half of my life trying to be great at uh.

01:16:08.300 --> 01:16:10.042
You know, there's a lot of time invested in that.

01:16:10.063 --> 01:16:15.990
I think I'd be cristiano ronaldo for a day excellent, all right, and thomas t, who would you trade places with for a day?

01:16:17.154 --> 01:16:19.199
really like any kid.

01:16:19.199 --> 01:16:24.009
I think it'd be fun to be a kid again, just to experience wonder and curiosity when the world's new, I mean.

01:16:24.009 --> 01:16:25.128
That's why I like I remember when, like you, were a kid again, just to experience wonder and curiosity when the world's new, I mean.

01:16:25.128 --> 01:16:28.688
That's why I like I remember when, like you, were a kid, in the summer days used to feel so long.

01:16:28.688 --> 01:16:35.695
Like days don't feel long anymore because we're not building any new experiences, like we were always learning and everything was new and exciting.

01:16:35.695 --> 01:16:46.283
So like days seem to drag on because I'm full of new experiences, lost that I mean I'm still curious and I still have wonder about the world, but I think that was even more so as a kid, so I'd be any kid for a day.

01:16:46.283 --> 01:16:48.828
Just recapture that perspective there you go.

01:16:48.868 --> 01:16:49.911
I love that and you're right.

01:16:49.911 --> 01:16:52.922
I think like routine has definitely made the days a lot shorter.

01:16:52.943 --> 01:16:54.148
Yeah that's for sure.

01:16:54.609 --> 01:17:12.801
well, gentlemen, thank you so much as always for your support, thank you so much for being great guests, thank you so much for the work that you're doing and just continue doing what you're doing, guys, because, sincerely, you guys are, are definitely making a change, well, actually making a difference in a lot of educators lives and in their practice too as well.

01:17:12.801 --> 01:17:21.699
And again, also, just really, I love the fact that you stay true to your pedagogy first tech, second approach, and not the other way around, as you know.

01:17:21.699 --> 01:17:23.050
That can definitely, you know, make a big difference.

01:17:23.050 --> 01:17:23.561
So can I say the same thing about you?

01:17:23.561 --> 01:17:25.192
Not the other way around, as you know, that can definitely, you know, make a big difference.

01:17:25.166 --> 01:17:25.355
So thank you.

01:17:25.355 --> 01:17:26.779
Can I say the same thing about you?

01:17:26.779 --> 01:17:30.400
I mean, we really appreciate you being the objective voice in the space.

01:17:30.400 --> 01:17:37.921
I don't see anybody else doing the work that you're doing and you know, bringing it to teachers directly from Founders Mouse or from anybody else.

01:17:37.921 --> 01:17:52.032
I think that anytime that you can get out the you know, cut through the BS of of the EdTech marketing scheme, I think that you do a great job of this and you know we just really appreciate knowing you and being affiliated with you in any way.

01:17:52.613 --> 01:17:53.797
Thank you, thank you, guys.

01:17:53.797 --> 01:17:55.240
I really appreciate that feedback.

01:17:55.240 --> 01:17:56.574
That goes a long way.

01:17:56.574 --> 01:17:57.739
It definitely fills my bucket.

01:17:57.739 --> 01:18:01.873
As a podcaster, I really appreciate that, and also just as an educator too.

01:18:01.873 --> 01:18:05.842
So I really appreciate those words, guys, and thank you so much for the encouragement.

01:18:05.842 --> 01:18:10.338
And again, my hat's off to you for all the work that you guys are doing and for all our listeners.

01:18:10.751 --> 01:18:18.859
Please make sure that you connect with Thomas Thompson, thomas Hummel All those links will be in the show notes, the Facebook group links also too as well.

01:18:18.859 --> 01:18:28.596
That way you can join that wonderful community and just to continue to learn from Thomas Thompson and Thomas Hummel, because they will reply to your messages.

01:18:28.596 --> 01:18:35.443
I mean talk about a place where you have founders that will listen and go ahead and share and do great things.

01:18:35.443 --> 01:18:36.847
This is a great community.

01:18:36.847 --> 01:18:39.256
So I definitely encourage you to join them.

01:18:39.657 --> 01:18:54.926
And again, please make sure you visit our website at myedtechlife where you can check out this amazing episode and the other 328 episodes that I promise you you will gain a lot of knowledge nuggets from that you can sprinkle onto what you are already doing great.

01:18:54.926 --> 01:19:07.192
And please make sure that you look for all the Edu8 episodes too, because you will find Thomas Thompson and Thomas H there also, as well as, like I mentioned to you, thomas t, fourth four-time guest first ever.

01:19:07.192 --> 01:19:08.654
So congrats on that.

01:19:08.654 --> 01:19:20.373
And of course, thomas h has joined this very special group too of a three-time guest, so thank you all for that and we got a solo episode fawn so I can catch up there you go.

01:19:20.654 --> 01:19:22.318
Well, hey, we'll throw that into.

01:19:22.318 --> 01:19:23.440
That way we can catch you up.

01:19:23.440 --> 01:19:24.523
Yeah, that's not a bad idea.

01:19:24.523 --> 01:19:25.835
So thank you all.

01:19:25.835 --> 01:19:27.038
As for all your support.

01:19:27.038 --> 01:19:31.630
Like I mentioned in the beginning, we do what we do for you to continue to bring you some amazing conversations.

01:19:31.630 --> 01:19:34.259
And thank you again to our show sponsors.

01:19:34.259 --> 01:19:41.190
Thank you so much to Book Creator, eduaid and Yellowdig we really appreciate it and, of course, my friends.

01:19:41.190 --> 01:19:44.431
Until next time, don't forget, stay techie.

01:19:44.431 --> 01:20:14.225
Thank you.
Thomas Thompson Profile Photo

Co-Founder

Thomas Thompson is one of the cofounders of Eduaide and a Social Studies teacher in Anne Arundel County Public Schools.

Thomas will earn his masters in educational technology from Johns Hopkins University in May 2023. His thesis examined trends in research design regarding the study of Open Educational Resource adoption. Before working on Eduaide.ai, Thomas founded Muckraker Media, a non profit organization working toward the expansion of the auditory public domain—free and openly accessible audiobooks and educational podcasts.

Thomas Hummel Profile Photo

Teacher and Eduaide Co-founder

7th grade science teacher. Co-founder of Eduaide.